ye zhanying ,camilla martin who is better?

[seawell]

Ye Zhao-Ying �@


Resume
Born on May 7, 1974 in Hangzhou, height: 175 cm, weight: 65 kg
Ye received professional badminton training at her childhood in Zhejiang Teenagers' Sports School, which laid solid foundation for her further development. In 1990, Ye was selected into the national badminton team. As a player good at attacking, Ye Zhao-Ying's playing style is noted for powerful, ferocious and swift killing smashes, and changeful and masterly skills. As an experienced badminton master player, Ye has the inborn physical qualities: her height, speed and
flexibility are best fit for playing badminton. Ye has won numerous world championship titles and has been at the top of IBF World Rankings for many times. She also contributed most for China's winning of World Championship Titles, World Cup Championship titles, and Uber Cup and Sudirman Cup.
Ye currently is one of Chinese top badminton players with best accomplishment records. She has for many years took the post of Chinese first ladies' singles player. At the year of 15, she was selected into the national team. In 1992, at the Uber Cup Competition, Ye, at the age of 18, won a key match for Chinese team with score of 2:1, which ensured China's winning of Uber Cup for five successive times. That year, Ye successively defeated power players from Indonesia and Korea and became a black horse in the world badminton circle. Henceforth, Ye became the first lady player of the Chinese badminton team.
�@�@ Ye was champion of ladies' singles at World Badminton Championships in 1995 and 1997, Yonex All England Open in 1997, General Finals of World Badminton Series Contest in 1997, Singapore Open in 1998, Asia Badminton Championship Competition in 1998. She was also major player of Chinese Badminton Team in wining Sudirman Cup in 1995 and 1997 and winning Uber Cup in 1998. At the 27th Olympic Games held in Sydney, Australia, Ye won the bronze medal of ladies' singles badminton competition. After the Olympic Games, Ye left the national team.
Honors Received
Honors Received
In 1992, elected as one of national top ten badminton athletes
In 1993, elected as one of Zhejiang Province's top ten athletes
In 1995, elected as one of national top ten athletes and one of Asia's top ten players
In January 1996, elected as one of national top ten badminton athletes
In 1998, elected as one of national top ten athletes
Ye Zhao-Ying in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In 1993, ranked the second in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In 1994, ranked the fourth in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In 1995, ranked the first in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In March 1996, ranked the first in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In April 1996, ranked the first in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In May 1996, ranked the second in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In Sept. 1997, ranked the first in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In Oct. 1997, ranked the first in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In January 1998, ranked the second in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In March 1998, ranked the second in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
On April 1, 1998, ranked the first in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
On May 15, 1998, ranked the first in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
On July 8, 1998, ranked the third in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
On Oct. 13, 1998, ranked the first in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
On January 28, 1999, ranked the fourth in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In July 1999, ranked the fifth in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
In Nov. 1999, ranked the second in the IBF World Rankings (Ladies' Singles)
Achievements
Champion of national youth badminton competition
In 1990, champion of the ladies' singles at World Youth Badminton Competition
In 1992, champion of the ladies' singles at Asia Badminton Championship Competition
In 1992, champion of the ladies' singles at Yonex All England Open
In 1992, champion of the ladies' singles at Indonesia Open
In Jan. 1993, champion of the ladies' singles at the 12th Yonex Japan Open
In March 1993, runner-up of the ladies' singles at the 7th France Open
In June 1993, took the third place of the ladies' singles at the 8th World Badminton Championship Competition
In July 1993, champion of the ladies' singles at Indonesia Open
In Oct. 1993, runner-up of the ladies' singles at Germany Open
In Oct. 1993, runner-up of the ladies' singles at Denmark Open
In Nov. 1993, runner-up of the ladies' singles at China Open
In Nov. 1993, champion of the ladies' singles at Hong Kong Open
In Dec. 1993, runner-up of the ladies' singles at the general finals of World Badminton Series Contest
In January 1994, runner-up of the ladies' singles at Yonex Japan Open
In March 1994, runner-up of the ladies' singles at Yonex All England Open
In April 1994, champion of the ladies' singles at Asia Badminton Championship Competition
In June 1994, champion of the ladies' singles at Asia Cup Competition
In July 1994, runner-up of the ladies' singles at Malaysia Open
In Oct. 1994, took the third place of the ladies' singles at the 12th Asian Games Badminton Competitions
In Nov. 1994, runner-up of the ladies singles at China Open
In Dec. 1994, runner-up of the ladies' singles at the general finals of World Badminton Series Contest
In March 1995, champion of the ladies' singles and runner-up of the ladies' doubles at Sweden Open
In April 1995, champion of the ladies' singles at Asia Badminton Championship Competition
In May 1995, defeated then word top players from Indonesia and Korea at the 4th Sudirman Cup
Team Championship Competition in Switzerland, which ensured China's winning of Sudirman Cup for the first time
In May 1995, champion of the ladies' singles at the 9th World Badminton Championship Competition
In August 1995, champion of the ladies' singles at America Open
In Nov. 1995, champion of the ladies' singles at China Open
In Dec. 1995, champion of the ladies' singles at national badminton championship competition
In Dec. 1995, champion of the ladies' singles at World Cup Badminton Series Contest
In January 1996, runner-up of the ladies' singles at China Taipei Open
In January 1996, champion of the ladies' singles at Yonex Japan Open
In March 1996, runner-up of the ladies singles at Yonex All England Open
In May 1997, won Surdiman Cup with her fellow players at the 5th Surdiman Cup Competition held in England.
In June 1997, champion of the ladies' singles at World Badminton Championship Competition held in England
In Oct. 1997, champion of the ladies' singles at the badminton competition of the 8th National Games held in Shanghai
In March 1998, champion of the ladies' singles at the 88th Yonex All England Open
In March 1998, runner-up of the ladies' singles at the Swiss Open
In May 1998, attended the Uber Cup Competition as a major player of Chinese team and China won Uber Cup at the competition
In Aug. 1998, champion of the ladies' singles at Singapore Open
In Sept. 1998, champion of the ladies' singles at Asia Badminton Championship Competition held in Thailand
In Oct. 1998, runner-up of the ladies' singles at Denmark Open
In Dec. 1998, attended the badminton competitions of the 13th Asian Games and won championship of ladies' teams for China
In Feb. 1999, took the third place of the ladies' singles at the general finals of the World Badminton Series Contest
In March 1999, champion of the ladies' singles at Yonex All England Open
In April 1999, champion of the ladies' singles at Yonex Japan Open
In May 1999, won Surdiman Cup with her fellow players at the 6th Surdiman Cup Competition held in Denmark
In Sept. 1999, champion of the ladies' singles at Asia Badminton Championship Competitions held in Malaysia
In Dec. 1999, champion of the ladies' singles at the general finals of World
Badminton Championship Competition
In April 2000, champion of the ladies' singles at Yonex Japan Open
In May 2000, won Uber Cup with her fellow players held in Malaysia
In September 2000, won bronze medal of the ladies' singles at the 27th Olympic Games held in Sydney, Australia




Martin is a very very good player.
But yezhaoying won 2 time in world badminton championships,camilla just i times.
yezhaoying won 3 times all england badminton championships's title,camilla just i times.
yezhaoying had won world cup,world grand prix finals,camilla hadn't won it.ye beat martin more than 10 times,camilla just 3 times.
so i think ye is better than martin!

[kwun]

i wonder how Ye will fare against the current set of Chinese players.

Ye if i remember correct was bugged by a string of inconsistent performance near the end of her career.

unfortunately, i don't have the priviledge to watch Ye play when she was at her best.

[dlp]

I think Ye benefitted from chinese team orders, she was the best of the chinese for a period, but Gong Zhicao eclipsed her at the end of her career. Camilla has proved the only challenge to almost three generations of chinese womens singles and has improved throughout her career, keeping pace with the top level over 13 years. Within this context I believe Camilla 's achievements are greater.

[seven]

I saw Ye play in the 1995 WC in Lausanne, and she was really very good!

Her career was somehow much shorter than Camilla's though.

Camilla also has the particularity of being the only european WS player to have reached the world's top level.
No other European can contest asian (and mainly chinese) hegemony in WS...

[seawell]

Ye zhaoying is my idol.
But i also like camilla martin.
Camilla martin and Ye zhaoying couldn't win olympic champion.
I think the europian love camilla more than zhaoying.In china ,we love zhaoying much more better than camilla.

[Qidong]

There is no comparision at all. Ye have won numerous major championships while Camilla won World Champion and All England only once, and she did it without many big name players around. Chinese women's team was at a slump when Ye started playing for China. Susi Susanti was still at her peak. And there were other good players like Mia Audina and Bang Soo Hyun. Ye was the only world class player in the Chinese team battling Susi, Mia and Bang days in and days out, and still managed to win so many major tournments. Her records against Susi and Bang are quite even. But look at Camilla, she never beated Susi, and very poor one-to-one records against Ye, Bang, and Gong.

I would rank Susi, Ye, Bang, Gong as great players, but Camilla, Mia, Dai Yun very good player but not able to reach the "great" level.

[kwun]

Camilla is a good player. the quality that is outstanding for her is not her head-to-head records, but instead is the length of her career, and how consistent she has played throughout her career. she may not be a the very top all the time, but she remains at 90% and continues to be a part of and a great threat to the top group players.

the top players comes and goes, susi, bang, ye, gong, but camilla is always there.

her longevity is one quality i think none of the WS player in recent can beat. not even the great Han Aiping and Li Lingwei managed to last that long.

she has mainly been injury free also, anybody remember when she had an injury?

[Qidong]

I think another reason Chinese players retired early was that they got burned out more easily because of the miltary style of training in China. I remembered watching on a TV show about how Gao/Zhang were trained. There were 2 coaches standing in front of the net smashing the birdies and Gao and Zhang were diving to the floor trying to save every birdie. That made me think of the Japanese Volleyball players in the 70's.

[other]

hehe...my defense might benefit from that kind of coaching burn out? too much training, body and mind can't take it anymore?

[Reynar]

Not only the training but china seems to have more talents then many other countires. Camilla has a long career but who would have kicked her off the team if she went through a little slump?. In China the players might not get a chance to continue on the team if they have too many bad results.

[Cheung]

Originally posted by Qidong
There is no comparision at all. Ye have won numerous major championships while Camilla won World Champion and All England only once, and she did it without many big name players around. Chinese women's team was at a slump when Ye started playing for China. Susi Susanti was still at her peak. And there were other good players like Mia Audina and Bang Soo Hyun. Ye was the only world class player in the Chinese team battling Susi, Mia and Bang days in and days out, and still managed to win so many major tournments. Her records against Susi and Bang are quite even. But look at Camilla, she never beated Susi, and very poor one-to-one records against Ye, Bang, and Gong.

I would rank Susi, Ye, Bang, Gong as great players, but Camilla, Mia, Dai Yun very good player but not able to reach the "great" level.

Are you saying when Camilla won the 1999 World Championships, Gong ZC and Ye ZY were not playing, and that is why Camilla won?

[yclin]

Originally posted by kwun


she has mainly been injury free also, anybody remember when she had an injury?

I have read that Camilla has back problems, and the wrist injury also forced her to withdraw from the Danish national championships this January.

[viver]

Originally posted by kwun
Camilla is a good player. the quality that is outstanding for her is not her head-to-head records, but instead is the length of her career, and how consistent she has played throughout her career. she may not be a the very top all the time, but she remains at 90% and continues to be a part of and a great threat to the top group players.

the top players comes and goes, susi, bang, ye, gong, but camilla is always there.

her longevity is one quality i think none of the WS player in recent can beat. not even the great Han Aiping and Li Lingwei managed to last that long.

she has mainly been injury free also, anybody remember when she had an injury?

Agree that Camilla is a very good player. But in China you know, competition for a place in the national team is just too tough. Not sure if Camilla would last that long if she was competed for a place in the Chinese team.

Longevity, few notice about lady players like Lin Ying - she was 15 years old when she was selected into the national team. Han Ai Ping won tournaments at 17 - this was around 1978 and she played until later 80's.

[viver]

Originally posted by dlp
I think Ye benefitted from chinese team orders, she was the best of the chinese for a period, but Gong Zhicao eclipsed her at the end of her career. Camilla has proved the only challenge to almost three generations of chinese womens singles and has improved throughout her career, keeping pace with the top level over 13 years. Within this context I believe Camilla 's achievements are greater.

Did Yeh benefit from team orders or not I am not sure. Though Yeh and Gong are both excellent players, but technically speaking Yeh is more complete player. Compare the variety and quality of both players technique. Consistency wise I agree Gong is better.

Camilla is without doubt an excellent player. Her achievements are great as a badminton player and also the one to provide some excitement in the ladies singles scene which is almost monopolized by the Chinese. Too bad Europe has not produced another lady player of her standard.

[seawell]

now camilla retired.she is old!

[Bbn]

From some of the expert commentary from tournamants

seems YE is the protege of Li Ling Wei and style very similar,

great deceptive strokes and pinpont accuracy but on bad days, just like

Li, or Zhao Jian Hua, can be disastrous and error prone.

Ye' s style always gets into trouble with Camilla or Susi, just like

LI always had problems against the persistent play of Han Ai Ping.

I think Zhang Ning is in a class of her own and was very much overlooked in 2003

for her achievements, her 3 matches in the 2003 World Champs were sheer magic.

[da ding]

I think the Chinese national team, more than any other country, can afford to employ the military training tactics. What with the 1.3 billion people the coaches have at their disposal, they will never run out of talent, even if because of the tough training regime each player only peaks for a short period of time. Much smaller countries like Indonesia, Korea, Malaysia and Denmark do not have the resources to do this, and i think the fact that so many players from these smaller countries can consistently challenge Chinese domination in this sport is an impressive achievemnet in itself.

In this respect, I appreciate the ruling for olympic qualification that a maximum of three players/pairs from each country are allowed in each discipline. This ruling gives players from less dominant countries more of a chance to compete, and hopefully there will be more players in the future not from the traditional asian giants together with denmark that are able to make an impression of the badminton world scene.

...even though i'm chinese...